Study Designs

A bioequivalence design is characterized by its subjects (each assigned to a sequence), its formulations (reference and one or more tests), its periods (the dosing occasions), and its sequences (which formulation is given at each period). The design is detected automatically from the sequence column; see detect_design and study_paradigm.

Supported designs

DescriptionFormulationsPeriodsSequencesReplicatedCrossoverNotes
RT or TR221NoYesSingle sequence, either ordering; treated as paired
R|T212NoNoThe common parallel design
RT|TR222NoYesThe common 2×2 design
RR|RT|TR|TT224FullyYesBalaam design
RTR|TRT232FullyYes
RTR|TRR232PartiallyYes
RTT|TRR232FullyYes
RRT|RTR|TRR233PartiallyYesThe common partial-replicate design
RTRT|TRTR242FullyYesThe common fully-replicate design
RRTT|TTRR242FullyYes
RTTR|TRRT242FullyYes
RRTT|RTTR|TRRT|TTRR244FullyYes
RTRT|RTTR|TRRT|TRTR244FullyYes
RR|TT222FullyNo
RST|RTS|SRT|STR|TRS|TSR336NoYes
ADBC|BACD|CBDA|DCAB444NoYes

A design is replicated when at least one formulation is administered more than once to a subject; this is what allows the within-subject variability of a formulation to be estimated (see Within-subject variability). Replication is fully replicated (every formulation repeated), partially replicated (some repeated), or non-replicated. In the supported partial-replicate designs only the reference is replicated, so only its within-subject variability σwᵣ is estimable.

  • EMA ABEL is available on any replicated design (partial or full).
  • FDA RSABE requires either the partially-replicated RRT|RTR|TRR design or one of the four-period fully-replicated designs RTRT|TRTR, RTTR|TRRT, or RRTT|TTRR. FDA RSABE for NTID additionally requires a fully replicated design (so that the test within-subject variability can also be estimated).
Washout between periods

In crossover designs the periods should be spaced by a washout long enough that there are no carryover effects from dosings in earlier periods. The models contain no carryover term, so the analysis assumes carryover is absent by design.

Paradigms

A run of pumas_be (or run_be), not a dataset on its own, is classified into one paradigm, which fixes the family of models available (see Models) and the criteria that can be assessed. The paradigm does not by itself pin down a single model: on the crossover paradigms custom_model (with homogeneity) selects between the fixed-effects and mixed-effects fits within the paradigm, whereas on the parallel and paired paradigms the model is fixed and custom_model is rejected. The nonparametric paradigm picks its rank procedure from the design, and accepts custom_model = SignedRankTest to pool the within-subject differences instead.

The paradigm is determined by the design together with options such as nonparametric; the chosen criterion does not change the paradigm but sets the inference options (including, for some criteria, custom_model) and drives the assessment within it. For example, nonparametric = true selects the nonparametric paradigm whatever the design (and the endpoint name can trigger it by default, e.g. Tmax), though not every design is then accepted; see Nonparametric paradigm.

The first column is the value study_paradigm returns, shown as it prints at the REPL. These names are not exported, so they are what you see rather than something you type: obtain the value by calling study_paradigm, not by referring to the name directly.

study_paradigm valueParadigmDescription
parallel_paradigmParallelIndependent groups, one formulation per subject (a Welch / two-sample t-test).
paired_paradigmPairedA single sequence over two periods (a paired t-test).
non_replicated_crossover_paradigmNon replicated crossover designEach subject receives each formulation once.
replicated_crossover_supports_abe_and_abel_onlyReplicated crossover (supports ABE and ABEL but not RSABE)A replicated design that supports standard ABE and EMA ABEL but not FDA RSABE.
replicated_crossover_supports_abe_abel_and_rsabeReplicated crossover (supports ABE, ABEL, and RSABE)A replicated design that additionally supports FDA RSABE.
three_formulations_paradigm / four_formulations_paradigm3 formulations / 4 formulationsCrossover designs comparing several test formulations against the reference.
nonparametric_paradigmNonparametricA rank procedure chosen by the design, selected for endpoints such as Tmax (or with nonparametric = true).